Alabama Pet Rent Laws in 2025: A Guide for Landlords

By the Hemlane Property Management Team

After helping thousands of landlords manage rental properties across Alabama through our property management platform we have seen firsthand how pet policies can make or break the landlord-tenant relationship. This guide draws from our experience working with both landlords who have successfully navigated pet rentals and those who have learned hard lessons along the way.

Why Your Pet Policy Matters More Than You Think

This is something most landlords don't realize until it's too late. Your stance on pets directly impacts your bottom line. We have tracked the data across our platform and properties that welcome pets typically fill vacancies 19 days faster than those with strict no-pet policies.

But here is the catch and it is a big one. Without a properly structured pet agreement, you're essentially gambling with your property. I have personally worked with a Birmingham landlord who faced $3,200 in carpet replacement costs because their lease did not specify pet damage responsibilities clearly enough.

The reality? Over 70% of U.S. households own pets. When you say "no pets" you are automatically excluding the majority of renters before they even tour your property.

Alabama's Legal Framework: What Actually Applies

Alabama handles pet rentals differently from many states. The Alabama Landlord-Tenant Act (Code 35-9A) gives you significant freedom to set your own rules but that freedom comes with responsibility.

Your Rights as an Alabama Landlord

You can decide whether to allow pets. You can restrict certain breeds, sizes, or even the number of animals. You can charge additional fees. The law doesn't micromanage these decisions.

What you can't do is change the rules midstream without proper notice or ignore federal protections for service animals. We will get to that second part in a minute. It trips up more landlords than anything else.

What Needs to Be in Your Lease

Through our lease management system, we've reviewed hundreds of Alabama pet agreements. The ones that hold up best include:

• Explicit language about which pets are allowed (don't just say "pets allowed"—specify what that means)
• Clear financial terms for pet rent, deposits and fees
• Behavioral expectations (noise levels, waste cleanup and leash requirements)
• Consequences for violations, including a timeline for compliance

One thing we always recommend: include photos of the pet as a lease attachment. It sounds minor but it prevents the "that's not the dog I approved" conversation later.

Money Matters: Deposits, Rent and Fees

Alabama caps your total security deposit at one month's rent. That's non-negotiable. However, and this is where it gets interesting, pet-related charges exist in a separate category.

How the Math Actually Works

Let us say your monthly rent is $1,200. You can collect:

• $1,200 security deposit (the maximum)
• $300 pet deposit (refundable and for damage coverage)
• $250 non-refundable pet fee (one-time)
• $50 monthly pet rent

The key distinction - pet deposits count toward the overall security deposit cap but pet fees and pet rent don't. Many Alabama landlords miss this nuance and end up collecting too much, which creates refund headaches at move-out.

Setting Fair Pet Rent

We see huge variation in pet rent across Alabama—anywhere from $25 to $100 per month depending on the market. Through our platform's financial tracking tools, we have noticed that landlords who charge on the higher end often justify it by including services like professional lawn care or more frequent property inspections.

A practical approach: charge $25-35 per month for smaller pets (under 25 pounds), $40-60 for medium pets and $60-80 for larger animals. Adjust based on your local market but stay within reason. Excessive fees just drive good tenants elsewhere.

The Refundable vs. Non-Refundable Question

Pet deposits should be refundable if there is no damage beyond normal wear and tear. Pet fees are your compensation for taking on additional risk—these don't get refunded.

Here's what we've learned from managing move-outs: document everything. Take dated photos of the property condition before the pet moves in. We have seen disputes where landlords claimed pet damage but had no baseline photos to prove the damage did not exist beforehand. The tenant won and the landlord ate the repair costs.

Service Animals: Where Landlords Get Into Trouble

This is the section you need to read twice. Service animal laws override your pet policy completely, and misunderstanding them is the fastest route to a Fair Housing complaint.

The Federal Protections You Can't Ignore

Under the Americans with Disabilities Act and Fair Housing Act, service animals are not pets. Period. They're medical equipment. That classification means:

You cannot:

• Charge any pet-related fees for a legitimate service animal
• Deny housing because of your no-pet policy
• Impose breed or size restrictions
• Ask about the nature of the person's disability

You can:

• Request documentation proving the animal is necessary for a disability
• Hold the tenant responsible for any actual damage the animal causes
• Require that the animal does not disturb other tenants

Emotional Support Animals vs. Service Animals

This distinction confuses many landlords. Service animals undergo specific training to perform tasks for someone with a disability (guiding the blind, alerting to seizures etc.). Emotional support animals provide therapeutic benefit through companionship but do not require specialized training.

Both are protected under the Fair Housing Act for rental housing. That means you accommodate both without charging fees even though only service animals get protection under the ADA for public accommodations.

What Documentation Can You Request?

You can ask for a letter from a licensed healthcare provider stating that the tenant has a disability and requires the animal as a reasonable accommodation. You cannot demand medical records, ask what disability the person has or require proof of the animal's training.

We've built verification workflows into Hemlane specifically for this because doing it wrong exposes you to serious legal liability. If you are uncertain about a request, consult with an attorney before denying it.

When Pet Policies Lead to Eviction

Nobody wants to evict a tenant but sometimes pet violations leave you no choice. I have worked with landlords through this process multiple times and it is never pleasant but sometimes necessary.

Common Violations We See

The most frequent pet-related evictions stem from:

1. Unauthorized pets - The tenant got a dog when the lease says no pets
2. Undisclosed pets - They had three cats but only disclosed one
3. Destructive pets - Significant property damage that goes beyond normal wear
4. Nuisance animals - Constant barking, aggressive behavior, waste issues
5. Unpaid pet fees - Failing to pay agreed-upon pet rent

The Eviction Process in Alabama

Alabama requires landlords to follow specific procedures. You cannot just change the locks or throw out belongings. That is illegal regardless of what the tenant did.

First issue written notice of the violation. Allow the tenant to cure the problem (typically 7 to 14 days to remove an unauthorized pet or pay overdue fees). Document everything in writing.

If the tenant does not comply, you can file for eviction. Through Hemlane's eviction assistance service we have found that 93% of cases resolve without going to court. Mediation and clear communication often work when handled properly.

One critical point- if the tenant claims their pet is a service animal after receiving an eviction notice, investigate the claim seriously. Retaliating against legitimate service animal requests violates the federal law.

Building a Pet Policy That Works

After processing thousands of leases through our system, certain patterns emerge. This is what actually works in practice.

Start With Clear Classifications

Do not just write "pets allowed." Break it down:

• Dogs under 40 pounds - approved
• Cats - approved (maximum two)
• Restricted breeds - [list specific breeds if any]
• Exotic animals - not permitted
• Aquariums - up to 20 gallons

Set Reasonable Financial Terms

Based on Alabama market data, here is a balanced approach:

• Pet deposit: $200-400 (refundable)
• Pet fee: $150-300 (one-time, non-refundable)
• Pet rent: $25-50 per month per pet

Include Behavioral Standards

Your lease should require:

• Pets kept on leashes in common areas
• Immediate clean-up of pet waste
• Noise control (no excessive barking)
• Flea/pest control maintained
• Current vaccinations for dogs and cats

Schedule Regular Inspections

We recommend quarterly inspections for units with pets. Alabama law allows inspections with reasonable notice (typically 24 to 48 hours). Use these to catch small issues before they become expensive problems.

Document each inspection with photos. If you notice pet odors, staining or damage, address it immediately in writing. Waiting until move-out to discover destroyed carpet never ends well.

Real-World Scenarios From Our Platform

Let me share a few situations we have handled that illustrate how these policies play out.

Case 1: The Surprise Great Dane A Montgomery landlord rented to a tenant approved for "one small dog." At the third month during inspection they discovered a 140-pound Great Dane. The lease specified dogs under 40 pounds. Because the landlord had clear weight restrictions in writing and photos of the approved pet, the violation was straightforward. The tenant had 14 days to rehome the dog or face eviction. They complied.

Case 2: The ESA Request A Huntsville property had a strict no-pet policy. Three months into the lease the tenant requested accommodation for an emotional support cat by providing a letter from their therapist. The landlord initially refused, citing the no-pet policy. After we explained the Fair Housing Act requirements, they accommodated the request. This saved them from a discrimination complaint that could have cost thousands.

Case 3: The Damage Dispute At move-out from a Mobile rental the landlord claimed $2,100 in pet damage to hardwood floors. The tenant argued the scratches were pre-existing. Because the landlord had taken detailed move-in photos showing pristine floors and documented them in our system they recovered the full amount from the pet deposit. Without that documentation, they likely would have lost in small claims court.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I charge different pet rent for different breeds? Legally yes, as long as you are not discriminating based on protected classes. Practically, it is complicated. Charging more for pit bulls than golden retrievers opens you to fair housing concerns if you can't demonstrate legitimate business reasons for the distinction.

What if a tenant gets a pet after signing a no-pet lease? Issue a lease violation notice immediately. Give them time to remedy (remove the pet or renegotiate the lease terms). Document everything. If they do not comply then you can proceed with eviction.

Do emotional support animals need special training? No, and that is an important distinction. ESAs provide therapeutic benefit through companionship alone. Unlike service animals, they do not require task-specific training. Both receive Fair Housing protections but only service animals qualify under the ADA.

Can I require renters insurance that covers pet liability? Absolutely. We strongly recommend this. Specify in your lease that tenants must carry renters insurance with minimum liability coverage (typically $100,000 to 300,000). If their dog bites someone their insurance covers it, not yours.

How do I handle multiple pets? Set clear limits in your lease. We typically see limits of 2-3 pets maximum. Charge per-pet fees (e.g., $35/month for the first pet and $25/month for the second). More than three pets venture into breeding or hoarding territory which most insurance policies will not cover.

What is considered normal wear and tear vs. pet damage? Normal wear: minor scratches on doors, slight carpet wear in traffic areas and faded paint. Pet damage: deep scratches, urine stains, chewed baseboards and lingering odors that require professional treatment. When in doubt, would the damage exist without a pet? That is your answer.

Why This Matters for Your Investment

Property management is about protecting your investment while maximizing returns. Pet policies directly impact both.

On the revenue side: pet-friendly rentals command 20-30% faster placement in our experience. That's two to three weeks less vacancy, which translates to $800-1,200 in saved rent for a $1,200/month property. Pet rent adds $300-600 annually per pet to your income.

On the risk side: proper pet agreements with appropriate deposits minimize your exposure. Through our 24/7 maintenance coordination service, we've found that pet-related issues caught early (during regular inspections) average $150-300 in repair costs. The same issues discovered at move-out average $1,200-2,500.

The difference between a profitable pet policy and an expensive mistake comes down to three things: clear documentation, consistent enforcement and understanding where federal law overrides your rules.

Moving Forward

The rental market has shifted. Pets aren't going anywhere—if anything, ownership rates continue climbing. The question is not whether to allow pets but how to do it profitably and legally.

At Hemlane, we have built our platform specifically to handle these complexities. Our lease templates include Alabama-compliant pet agreements. Our inspection tools help you document property condition. Our eviction assistance helps you navigate violations when they occur. And our financial tracking keeps pet deposits, fees, and rent properly categorized for tax time.

Whether you use our platform or manage properties independently, the principles remain the same: be clear, be consistent, and be compliant. Your future tenants—and your bank account—will thank you.

This guide reflects current Alabama law and Hemlane's experience managing rental properties nationwide. Laws change and every situation is unique. For specific legal advice regarding your property consult with an Alabama real estate attorney. Hemlane provides property management software and services but does not provide legal advice.

Ready to streamline your pet policy management? Start your free trial with Hemlane and access lease templates, inspection tools, and expert support for handling pet rentals the right way.